USA
Review: JA Kerswell
What isn’t a secret is that this film is very likely the worst of the post-SCREAM slasher movies. Terrible in almost every conceivable way, apart from some halfway decent production values and a killer who unexpectedly has Marty Feldman eyes.
A year after her boyfriend was axed to death in his dorm room, gormless college student Beth (Dorie Barton) is now dating fellow student hunky Hank (Joey Lawrence). Apart from the occasional nightmare in which her dead beau spills brains onto her from his axe wound, life is peachy for Beth, and she is excited to head out for Spring Break with her friends to Florida. The only wrinkle is that FBI Agent Owen Sackler (Jeff Conway) is still hanging around the dorm, asking her questions a year after the blood went cold.
Arriving at the coast, Beth and Hank are joined by four excitable friends: Tina (Leonora Scelfo, who acts like LuLu Fishpaw throughout and had a small role as a cheerleader in SCREAM (1996)), Nellie (future yoga podcaster Elsie Escobar), bro jock Oz (Thomas Anthony Jones) and the brooding Brad (Chad Allen). Hmmm. Who could the killer be? After an interminable half-hour of partying and screeching, one of their classmates is brutally slain outside a rave by a masked killer with those Feldman eyes, and Brad goes missing from their hired boat. Confined to their luxurious mansion, the friends do their very best to isolate themselves from each other so they can easily be offed, too, by the masked murderer in black robes …
Oh, boy. Where to start? I first saw DO YOU WANNA KNOW A SECRET (and probably the biggest mystery is where that question mark went in the title) shortly after it came out on video (it will probably come as a shock to no one that it bypassed theatres). A friend of mine, buoyed by the enjoyment she got from SCREAM (1996), I KNOW WHAT YOU DID LAST SUMMER (1997), URBAN LEGEND (1998) et al., excitedly plucked it from the Blockbuster shelves for a party viewing. As you can imagine, the party bombed, and I don't remember whether we ever made it to the end of the tape that evening.
Fast-forward to 2026, and I clung to the hope that nostalgia would at least warm me up to this movie, even if the memory left nagging doubts. Obviously, I am well-versed in the myriad pleasures a good bad film can deliver—especially with a group of friends, beer, and pizza. However, I watched it alone this time (how could I put anyone else through it again?). And? Well, it remains a painful experience (and I use the word experience advisedly). The first half of the movie has a gazillion attempted jump scares, and not a single one lands—and that really takes some doing. Not even a shameless lift from the infamous corridor scene in EXORCIST III (1990), nor one involving an ironing board, of all things. The central group fizz, bitch, and party, but no one looks like they are doing anything but acting. Hilariously, they succumb to cabin fever less than 24 hours after being confined to their luxury digs by the cops after the first murder. Presumably Joey Lawrence (who was in the previous year’s immeasurably better URBAN LEGENDS: FINAL CUT (2000) and is listed here as ‘Joseph’ to probably tell us that this is intended as a serious role) bailed before production wrapped, as he only features in the film’s would-be climactic scenes as a papier-mâché severed head. At least before that, he got to bust some moves in a highly choreographed, contrived martial-arts dance-floor fight scene. Honestly, I wish I’d bailed before the closing credits, too.
And so it goes on. The film features a scene in which the killer fakes their own death. Fair enough, you might think, but no one else is watching, only the camera. So it makes zero-fucking-sense. The killer even knocks out the same character THREE times rather than killing them, then gets to knock a wig off a woman’s head. Beth watches the murder of one of her colleagues with the blank expression of someone wondering if they left the oven on. Then we find out the film’s big secret is that the killer loves Beth and kills their shared friends rather than, you know, ask her out. Jeff Conaway wears a pained expression throughout, like someone hoping their cheque won’t bounce—and undoubtedly questioned his career choices when, in one scene, he has to argue with an unintelligible sprinkler repairman. And even Jack McGee (as the police chief) acts more like he’s in MACON COUNTY LINE (1974) than the law for some sleepy seaside town in Florida.
DO YOU WANNA KNOW A SECRET was filmed in Jupiter, Florida, in the late summer of 2000. It was executive produced by Del Tenney (who cameos here as an ill-fated pastor), the man behind films such as THE HORROR OF PARTY BEACH (1964) and I EAT YOUR SKIN (1971). Apparently, when asked, “How could you DO all these terrible films?” he replied, “Listen, I cry all the way to the bank”. He must have made a fair sum, as most of the film takes place at his palatial waterside mansion. Tenney co-wrote the film with Kermit Christman, who apparently founded the Palm Beach Shakespeare Festival 10 years earlier—and together they created their own tragedy with this. The local paper, The Palm Beach Post, ran an article on how to audition as an extra for the movie, for its beach and rave scenes. The piece offered guidance to men: “If you've got the body, don't be afraid to show it. If not, guys, remember this: Swim trunks good. Speedos bad.” The only time the film saw a silver screen was at the Palm Beach International Film Festival in April 2001, where the critic for the South Florida Sun Sentinel optimistically referred to it as a “horror-comedy”.
Most of the cast are listed as appearing in THE POOL 2 (2005), a supposed sequel to the Euro teen slasher THE POOL (2001). For a long time, this remained a mystery. The film does exist, but it is mostly recycled footage from DO YOU WANNA KNOW A SECRET, with some newly shot connecting scenes to cobble together a faux sequel for the Italian market, where THE POOL had been a modest box office hit. THE POOL 2 played briefly on Italian cinema screens and then vanished. Read more about it and see my discussion with the director on my Lost Slashers page.
Sadly, DO YOU WANNA KNOW A SECRET has none of the vim and camp of Tenney’s other horror films. It isn’t bad in a good way. It’s just bad.
BODY COUNT 9:
Female 3 / Male 6
Hysteria Lives! has been independently reviewing slasher movies since 1998. If this review entertained you or helped you discover a film, a $3 Ko-fi contribution helps cover the site's annual hosting and running costs.
DO YOU WANNA KNOW A SECRET (2001) - trailer